Teething toys go in the mouth for hours a day across months, which makes material the first thing to check and everything else second. Non toxic here means a specific set of things: food-grade silicone or natural rubber, free of BPA, PVC, phthalates, and lead, with no painted or coated surfaces that can wear away.
What to verify before buying:
- Food-grade silicone or natural rubber as the stated material, not just soft plastic
- Explicitly free of BPA, PVC, phthalates, and lead
- One-piece construction, or joined parts with nothing that can detach under sustained chewing
- No paint, dye, or coating on chewing surfaces
- CPSIA compliance, meaning the product has been tested against US federal limits for lead and phthalates in children's products
What CPSIA testing actually means: the Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act, established by the US Consumer Product Safety Commission in 2008, regulates materials in children's products. Itzy Ritzy works exclusively with CPSC-accredited laboratories, so compliance is verified by a third party rather than self-declared.
How to keep them safe in use: wash with warm water and mild soap after each use, rinse fully, and dry. Check the care instructions before dishwashers or sterilizers, since not every design tolerates heat. Inspect regularly and replace at any tearing, stickiness, or change in texture.
When does teething start? Usually between four and seven months, though it varies widely. Two or three teethers in rotation is enough for most families.
Is silicone safe for babies? Food-grade silicone is widely used in infant products because it is stable, does not leach at normal temperatures, and holds up to repeated cleaning without breaking down into small pieces. That stability is the main reason it replaced soft plastics in this category.
Browse silicone teethers, water teethers, or the full teething range.