Best Pacifier For Breastfed Baby

Choosing the appropriate pacifier for a breastfed baby is a significant decision for many parents. The choice involves more than just calming the baby; it’s about finding a pacifier that promotes the infant's health, growth, and the breastfeeding bond. This guide is designed to help parents select pacifiers suitable for breastfed infants, tackling issues like nipple confusion and supporting a positive breastfeeding experience.


Understanding Nipple Confusion

What Is Nipple Confusion?

Nipple confusion is when a breastfed baby starts finding it hard to latch properly on the breast after being exposed to different feeding methods, such as bottle-feeding or pacifiers. This confusion can disrupt the baby’s natural sucking rhythm, leading to ineffective breastfeeding sessions and potential distress for both mother and child.

Causes Of Nipple Confusion

Several factors contribute to nipple confusion. The primary cause is the difference in the sucking mechanism between breastfeeding and artificial nipples. Bottle nipples and pacifiers often require a different mouth movement, leading babies to adjust their natural feeding technique, which can then affect their ability to breastfeed effectively.

Impacts Of Nipple Confusion

Understanding the impacts of nipple confusion, such as diminished milk supply, painful latching, and fewer breastfeeding sessions, is crucial for parents. This knowledge assists in making informed decisions regarding the appropriate timing and method for introducing a pacifier.

Preventing Nipple Confusion

Prevention is key to avoiding nipple confusion. Parents are advised to wait until breastfeeding is well established, usually around 3-4 weeks, before introducing a pacifier. Additionally, choosing a pacifier that closely mimics the breastfeeding experience can help minimize the risk of confusion.

Features To Look For In A Pacifier For Breastfed Babies

Choosing the right pacifier for a breastfed baby involves more than picking the cutest design. To support your baby’s health and breastfeeding journey, consider the following key features when selecting a pacifier:

Shape And Size

The Itzy Soother™ Natural Rubber Pacifier - 0-6M is designed to mimic the shape and feel of a mother’s nipple, promoting a natural latch and reducing confusion. It's an excellent choice for supporting your baby's oral development and soothing them during breastfeeding transitions. This pacifier is made from 100% natural rubber, ensuring it's safe, soft, and comfortable for your little one.


The material of the pacifier should be safe, non-toxic, and durable. Silicone and latex are common materials, each with its own benefits and considerations.


Good airflow around the mouth is important to prevent skin irritation. Look for pacifiers with air holes or vents in the shield.

Orthodontic Benefits

Opt for the Sweetie Soother™ Orthodontic Silicone Pacifier 0-6M to effectively support your infant's oral development. Designed with an orthodontic shape, it promotes healthy teeth alignment and jaw development, ensuring a safe and soothing experience for your baby. This pacifier, made from 100% silicone, is a gentle choice for your little one's mouth and a practical solution for peaceful days and restful nights.

Easy To Clean

Maintain hygiene while ensuring comfort for your baby with the Sweetie Soother™ —Pacifier 2-Pack. These pacifiers are designed for easy cleaning and sterilization, reducing the risk of germ and bacteria exposure. Their safe and soothing design offers peace of mind for parents and comfort for babies, making them an excellent choice for maintaining cleanliness and calmness.

Tips For Introducing A Pacifier To A Breastfed Baby

Introducing a pacifier to a breastfed baby requires timing and patience to ensure it does not interfere with breastfeeding. Here are some tips to make this process smoother:

Wait For The Right Time

Introducing a pacifier after breastfeeding is well-established, usually around 3 to 4 weeks old is generally recommended. This helps prevent nipple confusion and ensures your baby has developed a good latch.

Choose The Right Moment

Introduce the pacifier when your baby is calm and content, not when they are hungry or fussy. This helps the baby associate the pacifier with comfort without replacing the need for feeding.

Let The Baby Lead

Place the pacifier near your baby's mouth and let them take it alone. Avoid forcing it; the baby should accept it willingly.

Monitor The Baby's Response

Observe how your baby reacts to the pacifier. If it seems to be rejected, wait and try again. The pacifier must remain a tool for comfort, not a source of distress.

Balance Pacifier Use

Use the pacifier to soothe your baby between feedings, but avoid overusing it. Ensure that your baby still has plenty of time for skin-to-skin contact and opportunities to nurse for comfort.

Maintaining Proper Oral Health

Ensuring proper oral health is crucial for babies, especially when introducing pacifiers. Here are some guidelines for maintaining your breastfed baby's oral health:

Regular Oral Cleaning

Even before your baby’s first teeth appear, cleaning their gums is important. Use a soft, damp cloth or a silicone baby toothbrush to gently wipe the gums twice daily, especially after feedings and bedtime.

Pacifier Hygiene

Keep pacifiers clean to avoid transferring bacteria to your baby’s mouth. Wash with mild soap and water and dry thoroughly. Avoid cleaning the pacifier with your mouth, as this can transfer oral bacteria to your baby. See your pacifier’s cleaning instructions to know how to care for it.

Monitor For Signs Of Misalignment

Regularly check your baby’s mouth for signs of misalignment or other oral health issues. Prolonged pacifier use can sometimes lead to dental problems such as overbite or crossbite. Consult with your pediatrician or a pediatric dentist if you notice any changes.

Limit Pacifier Time

As your baby grows, limit pacifier use to certain times, such as during naps or bedtime. This helps reduce the risk of developing dental issues while providing the comfort and security your baby may need.

Schedule Dental Visits Early

Schedule your baby's first dental visit by their first birthday or when their first tooth appears. Regular dental check-ups will help ensure their teeth and gums are healthy and developing correctly.

Can using a pacifier affect the duration of breastfeeding?

Evidence indicates that early and frequent pacifier use may shorten breastfeeding duration. However, if introduced correctly after breastfeeding is established, typically around 3-4 weeks old, it may not affect the breastfeeding period. Monitor your baby's response to the pacifier and use it for comfort, not as a feeding substitute.

How often should I replace my baby's pacifier?

Pacifiers should be replaced every two months or immediately if there is any sign of damage, wear, or tear. Regular checks are important to ensure the pacifier remains safe, as broken or worn-out pacifiers can pose choking hazards or become unsanitary.

Are there any specific techniques to help my baby accept a pacifier?

If your baby is reluctant to take a pacifier, you can try dipping it in breast milk before offering it to them. This can make the pacifier more appealing. However, ensure the pacifier is clean and that this technique is used sparingly to avoid creating an association that prevents the baby from accepting the pacifier otherwise.

Is it safe to attach a pacifier to a string or strap?

While attaching a pacifier to a strap can prevent it from falling on the ground, it is essential to use only straps specifically designed for this purpose and with a length that meets safety standards to prevent strangulation hazards. Never attach a pacifier to cords, ribbons, laces, or loose clothing.

What should I do if my baby starts to prefer the pacifier over breastfeeding?